Talk:can be able

Hello, you have come here looking for the meaning of the word Talk:can be able. In DICTIOUS you will not only get to know all the dictionary meanings for the word Talk:can be able, but we will also tell you about its etymology, its characteristics and you will know how to say Talk:can be able in singular and plural. Everything you need to know about the word Talk:can be able you have here. The definition of the word Talk:can be able will help you to be more precise and correct when speaking or writing your texts. Knowing the definition ofTalk:can be able, as well as those of other words, enriches your vocabulary and provides you with more and better linguistic resources.

RFD discussion: March 2019–April 2020

The following information has failed Wiktionary's deletion process (permalink).

It should not be re-entered without careful consideration.


A cursory Google search for "can be able" didn't yield any results about Indian English, mostly just people commenting how "can be able to do sth." is grammatically correct but obviously redundant semantically. Without a proper source I don't think this entry should be included. Wyverald (talk) 05:19, 11 March 2019 (UTC)Reply

  • Delete. Indeed, a news search found uses by a speaker from Papua New Guinea, by a Somalia-born Canadese minister and by the Korean president of Samsung Electronics, but nothing related to India. GBS yields some uses by Indian authors but many more from others, including native English speakers, going back to at least the 16th century (the trial of John Philpot, quoted as saying, “So that if you can be able to prove that ...”). So that I can be able to support the request.  --Lambiam 09:13, 11 March 2019 (UTC)Reply
  • weak Keep. I found some uses that are neither Indian nor African. I've labelled it as non-standard. It now looks very SoPpy to me...any other thoughts ? Leasnam (talk) 00:48, 5 April 2019 (UTC)Reply
  • Delete. SoP, for sure. Otherwise we would be able to open pages for any and all modal doublets, triplets etc. If this entry is allowed we might have to, mightn't we? -- However, the logical answer here is that the collocation of can with be able is in no way any different from the collocations of will, could (!), would, may, might, mightn't, wouldn't, couldn't (!), can't (!), and won't with be able. All these doublets indicate degrees of possibility to have the ability. The issue with "can be able" and "can't be able" and "could be able" is that they are less usually encountered due to them being a juxtaposition of two modal verbs where one is the infinite equivalent of the other. We find a similar situation with must have to. None of these doublets merit a special entry for any reason that I can fathom. ALGRIF talk 22:24, 9 November 2019 (UTC)Reply
The 2011 citation ("How can I be able to feel such sensation as pain?") is not well defined as a mere nonstandard variant of can. It has subtly different implications. Equinox 13:29, 5 March 2020 (UTC)Reply
If you rephrase it as "How is it that I'm able" or even "How is it that I can", it becomes apparent that it's structurally different, with the inversion due to the question just coincidentally mimicking the expected word order. In the same way, "How can I not?" isn't an example of "can not". Chuck Entz (talk) 13:51, 5 March 2020 (UTC)Reply
Deleted, though I moved the cites to the citations page just in case. - TheDaveRoss 12:49, 1 April 2020 (UTC)Reply